There is a law
of stern Necessity,
The immemorial ordinance of the gods
Made fast for ever, bravely sworn and sealed:
Should any Spirit, born to enduring life,
Be fouled with sin of slaughter, or transgress
By disputation, perjured and forsworn,
Three times ten thousand years that soul shall
wander
An outcast from Felicity, condemned
To mortal being, and in diverse shapes
With interchange of hardship go his ways.
The Heavens force him headlong to the Sea;
And vomited from the Sea, dry land receives
him,
But flings unwanted to the burning Sun;
From there, to the heavenly vortex backward
thrown,
He makes from host to host, by all
abhorred.
[Empedocles, c. 493 - c. 433 BC]
No one is free except
Zeus. [Cratos to
Hephaestus.
Aeschylus,
Prometheus
Bound 50]
"A free man?There is
no such thing! All men are slaves; some, slaves of
money; some, of chance; others are forced, either
by mass opinion, or the threatening law, to act
against their nature." [Hecabe 1 to
Agamemnon. Euripides,
Hecabe
864]
"We men are in prison all
that time which we choose to call life. For this
soul of ours, being bound and fettered in a
perishable body, has to endure many things, and be
the slave of all the affections which visit
humanity." [Flavius Philostratus, Life of
Apollonius of Tyana 7.26]
|
|
Ananke is Necessity, a great goddess with a
stern law ('unbearable', some think).
|
|
Goddess of Bonds
|
Ananke is the powerful deity that rules
compulsion, constraint, restraint, or coercion, and
presides over all forms of slavery and bonds,
starting with the basic necessities of life.
Consequently, when someone is cast into prison, or
fastened by chains, her name is evoked. For she is
behind all bonds, and has a share even in the ties
of kinship, friendship and love. She is called
Necessity; for once the attachment is established
there cannot but follow what necessarily is derived
from it, her might allowing no resistance.
Ananke's dominion is experienced mainly in the
physical world, and therefore she has been held
responsible for the ugliness of all violent
dealings deriving from her compelling power.
Accordingly, her rule is, not seldom, fought
against violently by ignorance; and when this
occurs new necessary bonds may appear as a result.
|
|
Double-edged bond
|
When it comes to the bonds of prisons and chains
there is at times little difference between
prisoner and guard, or between slave and master,
since Ananke's bond appears to tie them both. This
is why Hephaestus,
while chaining
Prometheus 1,
complained before Cratos (Power):
Hephaestus: Oh handicraft that I hate so
much!
Cratos: Why hate it?
Since in truth your craft is in no way to blame for
these present troubles.
Hephaestus: Nevertheless, I wish it had fallen
to another's lot!
Cratos: Every job is
troublesome except to be the commander of gods; no
one is free except Zeus.
Hephaestus: I know it by this task; I cannot
deny it. [Aeschylus,
Prometheus
Bound 45ff.]
Consequently, those who love freedom above all
consistently avoid the tasks that threaten to put
yet a chain round their neck, knowing that such
tasks would teach them, regardless of their
roleeither master or slavethat they are
not free.
|
|
Ananke's kingdom
|
Some have suggested that Ananke's kingdom is
primarily that of the physical world, since in it
no real freedom can be perceived. What is
necessary, specially the bare necessities of life,
is under her dominion; and in that sphere, no one
can choose to act according to his own view, but
instead must follow Necessity's dictates. This is
why some have regarded the body as 'the prison of
the soul', seeing that it is fettered to its own
functions and needs, which inevitably lead to want
and later to death.
|
|
Fate and blood bonds
|
On account of this inevitability, Necessity has
been called the mother of the
MOERAE (in whose hands
fate rests); and those who call her otherwise have
anyway said that she is steered by both the
MOERAE (for necessary is
also what must be, which is fateparticularly
death) and the ERINYES
(for these punish those who violently break the
bonds of blood).
|
|
All must obey
|
Since little choice is possible, and since there
is no escape for the body from the stern law of
Necessity, no one loves this goddess and everybody
ignores her cult. Yet her compelling
powerwith or without cultremains
unsurpassed in all circumstances. And given that
she must be obeyed unto the most minute detail,
this counsel has been given so that man might be
reconciled with his condition:
"If a man
endeavours to ... persuade himself to accept of his
own accord what needs must befall him, he will have
a very reasonable and harmonious life."
[Arrian's discourses of Epictetus, Fragment
8].
A similar thought occurred to rebellious
Prometheus 1 when he
was chained in Caucasus:
"I must bear
my allotted doom as lightly as I can, knowing that
the might of Necessity permits no resistance."
[Prometheus
1. Aeschylus,
Prometheus
Bound 104]
|
|
Compulsion in choice
|
But not only the purely physical is affected by
Ananke. For when someone feels forced either to
perform an evil act, or else to perform another
evil act, then he might as well evoke the goddess,
as when Agamemnon had
to choose either to suffer the consequences of
disappointing the army by not attacking
Troy, or else sacrifice his
daughter, the sweet flower
Iphigenia. And
although the king felt that both courses of action
were filled with evil, still he must choose. That
is why he complains, feeling that the nature of his
choice too well matched the dire straits of Aulis:
"Ah, woe is
me! unhappy wretch, what can I say? where shall I
begin? To what cruel straits have I been plunged! A
god has outwitted me, proving far cleverer than any
cunning of mine."
[Agamemnon in
Euripides'
Iphigenia
in Aulis 444]
|
|
Necessity and the soldier
|
Others are forced to choose the only thing they
themselves will deem possible, as when
Nestor arrayed his forces
in such a way that cowards, due to their position
in the ranks, would have to fight as brave men:
"Nestor put his charioteers with their
horses and cars in the front; and at the back a
mass of first-rate infantry to serve as rearguard.
In between he stationed his inferior troops, so
that even shirkers would be forced to
fight." [Homer,
Iliad
4.300]
This is the kind of pressure and compulsion that
Ananke makes possible.
And when a man is just a citizen, he is just the
subject of his ruler, or is bound just by law.
These bonds are indeed steered by Necessity. But
when a man, besides being a citizen, is a soldier
as well, he is not only bound to his country's laws
and ruler, but also to the army's regulations, to
his commander in chief, and to the officer
immediately above him. And if the army is at war,
then the bonds of Necessity increase even more,
since the enemy will force him to act, not as he
would like, but as he will need to if he wishes to
remain alive or to avoid becoming a prisoner of
war. Even so the outcome will not be in his hands.
On the other hand, when the war is over, the bonds
of Necessity decrease; and when he leaves the army
and becomes a civilian again, he sees them decrease
even more, being no longer subject to his
superiors.
|
|
Extra bonds
|
In similar manner, while a man is healthy, he is
subject mainly to the bare necessities of life,
naturally ruled by Ananke. But on falling sick, he
will be, in addition to those natural rules, under
the load of his sickness and the ordinances of his
physician, also ruled by Ananke indeed, since each
sickness has its necessary prescription, and no one
dreams of curing a serious disease just by
administering sweet cookies (unless one wishes to
see the patient's condition get worse).
And again, while a man is taken to be a good
citizen, he may be called 'free', or subject only
to the set of basic compulsions dictated by Ananke.
But the day he is believed to be a criminal, new
bonds appear to fetter him under the form of law
suits, persecution, or prison. And once convicted,
he will groan, not only under Ananke's basic set of
obligations, but also under those established by
his reclusion (ruled by Ananke as well, a
relentless goddess no doubt), since no one thinks
of hosting prisoners having in mind how they could
best enjoy themselves while in detention.
|
|
Circumventing through reduction
|
So in addition to the primary necessities of
life, many other bonds might be added or taken away
by Necessity, and they may go under a variety of
names, such as 'duty', 'responsibility', 'pledge',
'contract', 'punishment', 'sickness', etc. By these
words (and others like them) is sometimes meant the
yoke of slavery and the weight of fetters. Yet this
goddess has also been regarded as having a share in
all kinds of bonds, included those presided by
Love, Friendship, and moral
or civil obligation.
Since the fate of mortals is death, also this
one has been called necessary, being represented by
Ananke and her children, the
MOERAE. While
Death delays, however,
other things (also necessary) must arrive, such as
Old Age. But before the
arrival of the latter, mortals must still
submitbecause of their fragile physical
bodyto the necessities of life, enjoying no
other freedom than that represented by the
provisional gifts they might have received from
fate and other powers. Yet again, seeing that these
gifts also tend to become necessities in the mind
of man, fettering him in new ways, some advise to
have them, as far as possible, reduced or removed,
suggesting that real freedom can only be conquered
within:
For what purpose, then, did I
receive these gifts?
To use them.
How long?
For as long as He who lent them to you
wills.
But what if they are necessary to me?
Do not set your heart upon them, and they
will not be necessary to you. Do not say to
yourself that they are necessary, and they will not
be. [Epictetus 4.1.110]
But this reduction or removal cannot cancel the
dominion of the goddess, and is regarded just as a
way of honouring her by circumventing, through the
reduction of bonds, a power that can neither be
opposed nor avoided. It is as if they prayed: "Deny
me your gifts, goddess!" For these seem to them to
be those of bondage. And they, loving freedom,
cling to serene simplicity which knows few bonds.
|
|